Hoteller med pool i Shelter Island

"Comfortable Bed. Clean bathroom. Peaceful stay."

"The place is in dire need of a makeover. In the bathroom... No exhaust fan... Hinges and towel racks are rusted... Wall paper is peeling off the walls... Tub/shower faucet is connected wrong. Hot is cold and Cold is hot... Door has noticeable cracks. The front half of the room had no lights. Until this place get renovated, I will not stay there again."

"The property is very nice, quiet, and quaint. We stayed the night to head out on a fishing charter at 4am, and the location is literally walking distance. The room and property are very clean, and being greeted by very friendly staff was great after a long drive. The beds were comfortable, linens crisp and clean. The ceiling in the bath was a bit dated, but did not take away from a very comfortable stay. I booked through Expedia and the rate was the lowest in the area, and well worth the...

"The bedding smelled and the mattress was old. The rugs in the hallways were old and smelled . There was an odor throughout the motel. The staff was friendly and the price was reasonable but I will never book an Econo Lodge again. Extremely disappointed"

"The Penny Lane was an excellent place to stay if you are visiting Hampton Bays or surrounding area. Rooms are great. Bed was incredibly comfortable. Staff was excellent."

"Clean rooms. On the smaller side, so one full room barely comfortably seats 4 ppl. the pool was nice. the staff was very nice. comes with an outdoor seating area and a grill and a fire pit."

"A very comfortable stay - Noisy at night time with people returning to rooms talking loudly and closing doors."