Deluxe-værelse | Pengeskab på værelset, skrivebord, arbejdsområde til bærbare computere
Tjek tilgængelighed

Anmeldelser af Crest on Barkly

4 out of 5
Crest on Barkly
47 Barkly St, St Kilda, VIC

Anmeldelser

7,6

Godt

Bedømmelse på 10 − Fremragende. 269 af i alt 1002 anmeldelser" "
Bedømmelse på 8 − Udmærket. 404 af i alt 1002 anmeldelser" "
Bedømmelse på 6 − Okay. 175 af i alt 1002 anmeldelser" "
Bedømmelse på 4 − Dårligt. 88 af i alt 1002 anmeldelser" "
Bedømmelse på 2 − Forfærdeligt. 66 af i alt 1002 anmeldelser" "

8,0/10

Rengøring

8,2/10

Service og personale

7,6/10

Faciliteter

7,4/10

Overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter

6,8/10

Miljøvenligt

Anmeldelser

8/10 Udmærket

Christopher

Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Terrible internet. Loud, walls are pretty thin.
Overnattede 4 nætter i april 2024

4/10 Dårligt

Karthik

Reported a maintenance issue on my first day of stay but haven’t fix the issue
Overnattede 3 nætter i april 2024

2/10 Forfærdeligt

Steven

Rejste med familie, Forretningsrejsende
Synes ikke om: Rengøring, service og personale, faciliteter, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
This room was filthy upon checking in. Had to wait for it to be cleaned and it was still dirty when I went in afterwards. The tv did not work for the two nights I stayed there even though I complained to the front desk 3 times, they did nothing about it. Wasn’t even offered an apology, just ‘we will pass on the feedback’. Very disappointing and would never recommend anyone to stay here.
Overnattede 2 nætter i april 2024

10/10 Fremragende

Shane

Rejste med partner, Forretningsrejsende
Synes godt om: Service og personale, faciliteter, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Staff friendly. Room clean.
Overnattede 3 nætter i april 2024

8/10 Udmærket

N.

Rejste med partner
Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, faciliteter
We have regular hit and miss at the Crest. This stay was ok but a bit of a miss, not wholly the hotel’s fault. The neighbouring balcony, quite close, partied to 4:30am, the room smelt like men’s after shave had been sprayed to cover a damp smell, and we had to turn off the fridge coz it was so noisy and the milk was frozen! We turned it back on in the morning but wonder if this was why the room smelt. The bathroom was a bit ‘manky’ with grout that needed a good scrubbing. The bed was comfy, the room was spacious and the staff were lovely as always. The price was cheap but if this had been my only stay at this hotel I wouldn’t have returned. It is not a 4star hotel. More a 3 for this stay.
Overnattede 1 nat i april 2024

6/10 Okay

Miki

Forretningsrejsende
Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Bed was okay. Bathroom left a lot to be desired (mould in shower, the shower head bracket was loose). There's no sound protection with the room next door so I enjoyed the neighbours loud conversation till about 4.30am. New A/C was handy as it wasn't working last time I stayed here. Staff are great 10/10 service but the rooms need a big refurb.
Overnattede 1 nat i marts 2024

6/10 Okay

Ned

The staff were nice but the room i got was a little run-down and not spotless
Overnattede 1 nat i marts 2024

10/10 Fremragende

N.

Forretningsrejsende
Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, faciliteter, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Great stay. Neighbours a little rowdy both nights around 10pm for 5 mins but other than that, silent and clean. with big bed and big bath sheets. The only critique is the doona with big ink stains should have been retired from service. Otherwise a terrific stay.
Overnattede 2 nætter i marts 2024

4/10 Dårligt

Kaitlyn

Rejste i en gruppe
Synes godt om: Service og personale, faciliteter
Hotel was noisy from the boarding house next door also the shower smelt dirty maybe old mould smell other than that was ok, bed was comfortable.
Overnattede 1 nat i marts 2024

4/10 Dårligt

K

Synes godt om: Service og personale
Synes ikke om: Overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Overnattede 1 nat i marts 2024

8/10 Udmærket

Robert

Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale
Synes ikke om: Faciliteter
Room good value, breakfast not worth it as terrible coffee, no hot breakfast Mon-Fri.
Overnattede 2 nætter i februar 2024

4/10 Dårligt

Camryn

Synes godt om: Service og personale
Synes ikke om: Rengøring, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
had to pay extra for a 3rd guest who did not receive any bedding options then had to pay $50 per night for an uncomfortable roll out bed. there was hair all through the bed and stains all over bedding. this was fixed. had to ask for a towel for the 3 person multiple times aswell as a roll of toilet paper. location was good and staff were friendly and offered beverage as on them for the inconveniences of the stains but we would have preferred just receiving adequate supplies for 3rd guest.
Overnattede 4 nætter i februar 2024

6/10 Okay

Blair

Overnattede 1 nat i februar 2024

8/10 Udmærket

michael

Rejste med partner
Synes godt om: Service og personale
Synes ikke om: Overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
i have stayed here a couple of times before in a much bigger and better room for a lot less money, this room was small, and showing obvious signs off wear, Paint all over the alarm clock marks all over the walls cornice cracking vent in bathroom coming off chipped tiles carpet pulling up and frayed near bathroom all this for nearly $500 not happy nor impressed, will not stay here again , will find a new hotel for my Melbourne visits from not on
Overnattede 1 nat i februar 2024

8/10 Udmærket

Courtney

Rejste i en gruppe
Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, faciliteter, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Older style apartment but very spacious and clean. Staff were very nice and helpful.
Overnattede 3 nætter i februar 2024

6/10 Okay

Miki

Synes godt om: Service og personale
Synes ikke om: Overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Overnattede 3 nætter i februar 2024

10/10 Fremragende

Mandela

Rejste med familie
Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, faciliteter, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
the room we stayed in was clean and room service had kept it extra clean in the morning. the staff was nice and approachable, the property was quiet and easily accessible by tram from the city.
Overnattede 2 nætter i februar 2024

10/10 Fremragende

Gabriel

Rejste med partner
Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, faciliteter, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
It was lovely, easy to check in and out , friendly staff. Comfortable room with all the basics supplied
Overnattede 1 nat i februar 2024

8/10 Udmærket

jay

Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Overnattede 1 nat i februar 2024

4/10 Dårligt

andrew

Synes ikke om: Rengøring, service og personale, faciliteter, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
The room was filthy with massive amounts of mold in the bathroom and dust all over the benches. The reception staff took a scan of my credit card to store in their computer as well as my photo ID. There is no requirement for that information to be stored and it allows anyone with access to their computer to steal my details. Poor service disgusting room that was filthy. I took pictures of the state of teh room as it was so bad.
Overnattede 1 nat i februar 2024

8/10 Udmærket

Noah

Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale
Convenient to where I needed to be. It was quiet. The breakfast was a bit on the expensive side for what was on offer
Overnattede 4 nætter i januar 2024

6/10 Okay

Natalija

Rejste i en gruppe
Synes godt om: Service og personale
It was book completely diferent room
Overnattede 1 nat i januar 2024

8/10 Udmærket

Fiachra

Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale
Decent hotel that looks like it has seen better days but is good for a few days. Small gym, laundry, parking, café/bottleshop and bar on-site Good tram-connections nearby and walking distance to lots of amenities on Fitzroy street, St. Kilda beach and Albert Park
Overnattede 2 nætter i januar 2024

10/10 Fremragende

Leana

Rejste med partner
Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, faciliteter, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Clean and fairly quiet. Reasonably priced. Would stay again. Would recommend to my friends.
Overnattede 2 nætter i januar 2024

10/10 Fremragende

Peter

Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Overnattede 1 nat i januar 2024

8/10 Udmærket

peter

Synes godt om: Service og personale, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Didnt like a room with an adjoining door..the people in the room next door sounded like they were in MY room at 12.30am.
Overnattede 1 nat i januar 2024

8/10 Udmærket

Wayne

Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, faciliteter, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Nice clean property and big room in a very convenient location. Could not complain about anything.
Overnattede 1 nat i januar 2024

6/10 Okay

Jeannie

Synes godt om: Rengøring, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter, værelsets komfort
Middle of the road hotel. Better options close by.
Room was quite small. Bathroom was tiny. Bed was comfortable enough. Very noisy when people were exiting early in the morning. We felt Crest on Park was a better hotel. We won't be staying at Crest on Barkly again.
Overnattede 1 nat i januar 2024

6/10 Okay

Verificeret rejsende

Rejste med familie
Synes godt om: Service og personale
Ok basic hotel not 4 star!!! Needs work done!
Not the best hotel. A bit run down in need of some work. Shower terrible pressure. Soft pillows. Room wasnt clean clean. Windows so dirty couldnt see out of. The hotel says at check in takes a holding fee for deposit incase of damages. We asked if money is taken off card to advoud card charges. We were told no its just a holding fee. Not true. Hotel took money off and hols it for 5 to 7 days !!!! Shocking in this day in age. To hold onto peoples money. When discussed at checkout , lady on reception said this is normal for hotels here. No its not we travled all around the world and have never had a hotel take extra money and keep it for a week after we leave!!! Wont be back and wouldnt recommend.
Overnattede 1 nat i december 2023

8/10 Udmærket

Cassandra

Rejste med familie
Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Was clean
Overnattede 3 nætter i december 2023

8/10 Udmærket

Harley

Overnattede 4 nætter i december 2023

8/10 Udmærket

Michael

Synes godt om: Service og personale, faciliteter
Synes ikke om: Overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Overnattede 1 nat i december 2023

2/10 Forfærdeligt

Paul

Rejste med familie og småbørn
Synes ikke om: Rengøring, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Checked out a day and a half early. Room was dirty on arrival, guest in next room was up all night being sick and making weird noises and some not so friendly drunk guest tried to snatch my child’s pizza. On checking out was not even asked if there was a problem by the desk. Very disappointed
Overnattede 3 nætter i december 2023

10/10 Fremragende

Ross

Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Overnattede 1 nat i december 2023

10/10 Fremragende

Stuart

Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Very good and great value.
Overnattede 1 nat i december 2023

10/10 Fremragende

stephen

Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
It was a nice place to stay
Overnattede 1 nat i december 2023

10/10 Fremragende

Mark

Rejste med partner
Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Great staff, comfortable bed, everything we needed for our stay. Affordable
Overnattede 1 nat i december 2023

10/10 Fremragende

Andrew

Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Easy to get from the hotel to the city by tram
Overnattede 2 nætter i november 2023

10/10 Fremragende

Tracey

Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Overnattede 1 nat i november 2023

8/10 Udmærket

victoria

Rejste med partner
Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, faciliteter, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
The check in was easy, very friendly staff. Our room was clean, comfortable and had what we needed. We had a car, but walked to the restaurant area easily, approx 15 minute walk. Felt safe walking around the area. Public transport is right out the door. Its a great location. Its good value for money and would stay here again. The staff were all helpful and friendly.
Overnattede 2 nætter i november 2023

2/10 Forfærdeligt

Eric, Cherrybrook

Rejste med familie
Synes ikke om: Service og personale, faciliteter, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Terrible room facilities & customer services - In bathroom, shower mixer and exhaust fan malfunction, towel rail loosened out and moulding around window sills. Complaints to front desk 2 times on Day 1 & 2, but no improvement and feedback. Eventually, strike for room changing on Day 3 with reception. No communication with different shifts of their front desk manager. STRONGLY NOT RECOMMENDED.
Overnattede 3 nætter i november 2023

8/10 Udmærket

Bruce

Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Convenient to Alfred Hospital, quite walkable down to St Kilda, esplanade for dining.
Overnattede 1 nat i november 2023

6/10 Okay

Glenn

Synes godt om: Service og personale, faciliteter, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
Parking
Overnattede 1 nat i november 2023

6/10 Okay

Gabriel

Rejste med partner
Synes godt om: Service og personale
Position good Property very average
Overnattede 7 nætter i november 2023

4/10 Dårligt

Rutwik

Synes ikke om: Service og personale, faciliteter
Stay was good. We arrived as a party of 4 but they only provided 2 towels - when asked to provide for more they informed us that the laundramat was closed and more towels couldn't be provided. Stay would definitely be a 4/5 rating if it weren't for that.
Overnattede 2 nætter i november 2023

10/10 Fremragende

Anatoli

Big rooms
Overnattede 1 nat i november 2023

6/10 Okay

Narelle

Synes godt om: Rengøring, overnatningsstedets tilstand og faciliteter
A lot of noise from the corridors can be heard in the room
Overnattede 1 nat i november 2023

2/10 Forfærdeligt

Wayne

Synes ikke om: Service og personale
Overnattede 1 nat i november 2023

8/10 Udmærket

Melanie

Overnattede 1 nat i oktober 2023

6/10 Okay

Grant

Synes godt om: Rengøring, service og personale, faciliteter
Guys the no ventilation and lack of air circulation is a worry. No windows in rm 05? Corridor and rooms smell a bit like an old brothel ... (Let me know if it is!😉) Reception staff are awesome!
Overnattede 1 nat i november 2023