If you're looking for an out of the way spot to relax and get off the grid, this place is 5 stars. If you are looking for creature comforts and privacy within the house, this place is 3 stars. Hence, I've given it a 4. We enjoyed our stay. It is peaceful on the crystal clear pond, the mattresses are comfortable, and the deck is a great place to play games, eat, or read. I say mattresses, though, because in some instances there is no frame, just the box spring and mattress. The rental description should not read 3 bedrooms. It is one bedroom and an open loft that would be good for close friends/family. However, if you have more than one couple, or anyone else that prefers their own sleeping space, this may not work. We had no problem with cell service (AT&T), but were thankful for the recent addition of WiFi. The hosts were super responsive, giving needed info to make our stay nice, but we may not have been prepared if I had not posed questions for that response. Overall, Green Door is worth the trip provided you know what to expect.